Advanced Search

BSCP 40: Change Management

v 22.0
Download Forms
Download

Balancing and Settlement Code

BSC PROCEDURE

CHANGE MANAGEMENT

BSCP40

Version 22.0

Date: 29 February 2024

BSC PROCEDURE 40 relating to CHANGE MANAGEMENT

1. Reference is made to the Balancing and Settlement Code dated Code Effective Date and, in particular, to the definitions of “BSC Procedure” in Section X, Annex X-1 thereof.

2. This is BSC Procedure 40, Version 22.0 relating to Change Management.

3. This BSC Procedure is effective from 29 February 2024.

4. This BSC Procedure has been approved by the BSC Panel.

Intellectual Property Rights, Copyright and Disclaimer

The copyright and other intellectual property rights in this document are vested in Elexon or appear with the consent of the copyright owner. These materials are made available for you for the purposes of your participation in the electricity industry. If you have an interest in the electricity industry, you may view, download, copy, distribute, modify, transmit, publish, sell or create derivative works (in whatever format) from this document or in other cases use for personal academic or other non-commercial purposes. All copyright and other proprietary notices contained in the document must be retained on any copy you make.

All other rights of the copyright owner not expressly dealt with above are reserved.

No representation, warranty or guarantee is made that the information in this document is accurate or complete. While care is taken in the collection and provision of this information, Elexon Limited shall not be liable for any errors, omissions, misstatements or mistakes in any information or damages resulting from the use of this information or action taken in reliance on it.

AMENDMENT RECORD

Version

Date

Description of Changes

Changes Included

Mods Panel Ref

1.0

Code Effective Date

Designated version

N/A

2.0

27 March 2001

Addition of an Error Correction Process

P/15/012

3.0

25 February 2003

Operational Review

CP871

ISG/24/268

SVG/24/313

4.0

1 May 2003

Approved for use

ISG/27/307

SVG/27/365

5.0

30 June 2004

CVA Programme June 04 Release

CP971, CP998, CP1002, CP1008

ISG/40/003 SVG/40/004

6.0

BETTA Effective Date

CVA Feb 05 Release

BETTA 6.3, CP1091, CP1069, CP1073, CP1074, CP1075, CP1076, CP1077

SVG/49/003

ISG/50/001

7.0

02 November 2005

CVA Programme Nov 05 Release

P187

P/94/004

8.0

22 February 2007

February 07 Release

CP1170

SVG/69/004

ISG/70/002

9.0

23 August 2007

Standalone Release

P197

Panel

10.0

5 November 2009

November 09 Release

CP1284

ISG100/01

SVG100/01

11.0

31 December 2010

Standalone Release

P262, P263

Panel

12.0

6 November 2013

Standalone Release

P296

P216/04

13.0

3 June 2014

Standalone Release

P301

P224/07

14.0

5 November 2015

November 2015 Release

P305

ISG172/04

SVG176/03

15.0

3 November 2016

November 2016 Release

CP1468

ISG185/01

SVG188/02

16.0

22 February 2018

February 2018 Release

CP1494

ISG200/09

SVG202/03

17.0

29 March 2019

29 March 2019 Standalone Release

P369

P285/12

29 March 2019 Standalone Release

CP1511

P285/10

18.0

3 April 2019

Standalone Modification

P370

P287/06

19.0

27 June 2019

27 June 2019 Release

P372

P290/07

20.0

16 June 2020

16 June 2020 Release

P405 Self-Governance

P302/08

21.0

1 September 2021

1 September 2021 Non-Standard Release

P420

P316/05

22.0

24 February 2024

29 February 2024 Standard Release

CP1584

IG268/02

SVG270/02

1.1. Purpose and Scope of the Procedure

1.1.1 Purpose

This BSC Procedure (BSCP):

    • outlines the Change Management processes invoked to progress and implement changes to the BSC and BSC Configurable Items to ensure that all changes are introduced in a controlled and auditable manner.

    • defines the process for Third Party Applicants to request designation to raise a Modification Proposal; and

    • defines a pre-change process for Issues.

One of the objectives of this procedure is to maintain the integrity and robustness of the BSC Configurable Items and supporting products and to ensure that all changes are introduced in a controlled and auditable manner. This is achieved by:

    • implementing the change management procedures within the BSC;

    • assessing all proposed changes and assisting the BSC Panel and its Committees in making informed decisions;

    • consulting with interested parties how work will be progressed;

    • implementing new, or revisions to existing, BSC Configurable Items; and

    • producing the BSC Baseline Statements.

1.1.2 Out of Scope

This procedure does not cover changes to associated Core Industry products or the System Operator-Transmission Owner Code (STC). The System Operator within the STC is NETSO. However, where proposed changes to the BSC or BSC Configurable Items would result in a corresponding change to the Core Industry Documents or the STC BSCCo will liaise with the relevant bodies to ensure the appropriate change documentation is raised.

This procedure does not cover changes to BSC Parties’ or their Agents’ systems and procedures which may be necessary for participants to implement any changes that are made to the BSC or BSC Configurable Items. Party Agents must consider whether any potential changes would trigger the need for Re-Qualification by assessing the risk that implementing the corresponding changes within their own organisations would pose to the Balancing and Settlement arrangements as described in BSCP537.

1.1.3 Modification Proposals

A Modification Proposal is required to amend the BSC Sections. This procedure sets out the procedure for the submission of Modification Proposals, which is derived from Section F of the BSC (the ‘Modification Procedures’). Any consequential changes to BSC Configurable Items arising from a Modification Proposal may be made under that Modification Proposal and does not require a separate Change Proposal to be raised.

To raise a Modification Proposal, Parties must submit a completed Modification Proposal form to BSCCo. BSCCo must publish the Modification Proposal form template on the BSC Website for use by Parties. Guidelines for completing this form are contained within the form itself.

1.1.4 Change Proposals

A Change Proposal is required to effect changes to BSC Configurable Items where no changes to BSC Sections are required. To raise a Change Proposal, Proposers must submit a completed BSCP40/02 ‘Change Proposal’ form to BSCCo in accordance with Section 3.4. Any interested person may submit a CP. BSC Parties are considered interested persons by default. Guidelines for completing this form are contained within the form. Section 3.5 sets out the process for obtaining the Panel Committee decision and Section 3.6 sets out the process for the implementation of Change Proposals.

1.1.5 Draft Change Proposals

This procedure also contains standard forms for raising Draft Change Proposals to allow participants to comment on or discuss a particular issue and solution prior to a Change Proposal being raised.

1.1.6 Change Proposal Circulars

Change Proposal Circulars (CPC) will be used to communicate all change management information relating to Change Proposals and related changes to Category 1 and 2 BSC Configurable Items to BSC Parties and Party Agents, in accordance with the process set out in Section 3.1. BSCCo publish all CPCs on the BSC Website.

1.1.7 BSC Baseline Statement

The BSC Baseline Statement is a list of each BSC Section and BSC Configurable Item, showing:

    • the master version;

    • the effective date of the master version;

    • the Modification Proposals and / or Change Proposals implemented since the previous master version;

    • the “Responsible Committee(s)” for the approval of changes to it; and

    • the categorisation of BSC Configurable Item.

A new version of the BSC Baseline Statement will be produced when new versions of one or more BSC Sections and / or BSC Configurable Items become effective.

1.1.8 Submission of Issues

Where a Party or interested third party feels that it has an issue, problem, defect or improvement with the BSC arrangements, but is unsure of how or whether to progress the concern, or wants to explore the solution options, an Issue should be raised. This pre-change process shall assist in the framing of issue(s)/defect(s) and possible CPs or Modifications. Parties, interested third parties (including bodies representative of interested third parties and Party Agents) and BSCCo, may raise an Issue in accordance with section 3.15 below.

Panel Committees may be consulted by the proposer of the Issue in order to seek guidance. The Panel Committees would then advise on any possible solution to the concern and how best to resolve the problem, e.g. to raise a Change Proposal, or form an Issue Group.

Issue Groups shall adhere to the Issue Group Terms of Reference, which shall be set and maintained by the Panel and published on the BSC Website.

Unless an Issue is withdrawn by the proposer, an Issue Report shall be presented to the Panel following the assessment and discussion of the Issue.

1.1.9 BSC Change Communication

All interested persons should register on the BSC Website (or be registered by BSCCo – by raising a Service Desk ticket on the BSC Website) to receive by email communications which support the Modification Procedures, Change Proposal process and Issue process, by providing relevant contact details to BSCCo. It is expected that new Parties, or individuals from those organisations applying for Qualification, register for BSC change notices. Interested persons can sign up for addition to the BSC Change Distribution List and/or the BSC Release Distribution List.

The provisions concerning general email communications from BSCCo to Parties are contained in Section H of the BSC. It is the responsibility of Parties and Party Agents to register for BSC change notices. All interested parties, as listed in Section F of the BSC as well as Party Agents should register for these two distribution lists.

The BSC Change Distribution List will be used to send change notices up to and including approval of the CP or Modification and closure of Issues.

The BSC Release Distribution List will be used to send change notices after the CP or Modification has been approved.

1.2 Main Users of the Procedure and their Responsibilities

The main users of this procedure are:

    • BSCCo – manages the change process.

    • BSC Panel.

    • Citizens Advice and Citizens Advice Scotland

    • Market Index Data Providers (MIDP).

    • Panel Committees - control all changes to Configurable Items, apart from modifications to the BSC.

    • Parties and Party Agents

    • Interested third parties (including Party Agents) or any bodies representative of interested third parties – to raise Issues.

    • Third Party Applicants – to request designation by the Panel or the Authority to raise Modification Proposals.

Draft Change Proposal Consultation

During the change management process, Draft CPs may be issued as part of the agreed timetabled Change Proposal Circular notified via the Change Distribution List for consultation. For more information on this process, please see section 3.2 of this procedure.

CP Impact Assessment

During the change management process, CPs will be sent to the Change Distribution List as part of the agreed timetabled Change Proposal Circular, detailing the issue and solution for Impact Assessment. Interested parties are invited to comment via the Change Distribution List on CPs and their attachments and, where relevant, review associated draft redline changes. In particular Parties and their Qualified Agents will be expected to comment on support for the CP, detail impacts of the CP, provide implementation notification timescales and agree the proposed Implementation Date (if they do not, they will be asked to provide an alternative Implementation Date). The timetable for CP Impact Assessment is available as part of the Change Register published on the BSC Website. For more information on this process, please see section 3.4 of this procedure.

Please note that De Minimis BMRS CPs will not be subject to the full Impact Assessment process (as described in 3.4 below), unless queried during the objection window.

Panel Committee Approval of Change Proposals

Once the appropriate Panel Committee(s)1 has approved a CP, and associated redlined text, the CP becomes final and no further versions of the CP, or amendments to the redline text, can be produced without the raising of a separate Change Proposal.

1.3 Key Milestones

There are no key milestones in this procedure.

1.4 BSC Provisions

This BSCP should be read in conjunction with the BSC and in particular Section F. This BSCP has been produced in accordance with the provisions of the BSC. In the event of an inconsistency between the provisions of this BSCP and the BSC, the provisions of the BSC shall prevail.

1.5 Associated BSC Procedures

This procedure interfaces with the following:

BSCP507

Supplier Volume Allocation Standing Data Changes

BSCP509

Changes to Market Domain Data

BSCP537

Qualification Process for SVA Parties, SVA Party Agents and CVA MOAs

2 Acronyms and Definitions

2.1 List of Acronyms

The following is a list of acronyms used in BSCP40:

BSCCo

Balancing and Settlement Code Company

CP

Change Proposal

CPC

Change Proposal Circular

DCP

Draft Change Proposal

EMDS

Energy Market Data Specification

IA

Impact Assessment

MIDP

Market Index Data Provider

MIDS

Market Index Definition Statement

NETSO

National Electricity Transmission System Operator as the holder of the Transmission Licence and any reference to “NETSO”, “NGESO”, “National Grid Company” or “NGC” in the Code or any Subsidiary Document shall have the same meaning.

REC

Retail Energy Code (REC)

STC

System Operator-Transmission Owner Code

2.2 List of Definitions

The following is a list of definitions used in this BSCP:

    • Baseline – the master version of each BSC Section and BSC Configurable Item.

    • BSC Baseline Statement – as defined in Section 1.1 and shall be revised on the implementation of one or more changes to any BSC Section(s) and/or BSC Configurable Item(s) on a single day.

    • BSC Change Distribution List – a list of email addresses for BSC Parties, Party Agents and any other interested persons, to be used for sending notices related to Issues, DCPs, CPs and Modifications.

    • BSC Configurable Item – all Code Subsidiary Documents, plus other documents and systems, as agreed by the BSC Panel to be changed in accordance with this procedure, and included in the BSC Baseline Statement.

    • BSC Release – discrete set of activities which will implement changes and/or correct errors by amending one or more of the BSC Configurable Items.

    • BSC Release Distribution List - a list of email addresses for BSC Parties, Party Agents and any other interested persons, to be used for sending notices related to the implementation of CPs and Modifications.

    • BSCCo – functional responsibility for the purpose of managing the change process in accordance with the BSC and this BSC Procedure.

    • Category 1 BSC Configurable Item – a BSC Configurable Item that imposes obligations on BSC Parties and/or Party Agents, as such BSC Panel believe redline drafting of the proposed changes to the BSC Configurable Item must be included with the Change Proposal.

    • Category 2 BSC Configurable Item – a BSC Configurable Item that does not impose obligations on BSC Parties and/or Party Agents, as such the BSC Panel do not believe redline drafting of the proposed changes to the BSC Configurable Item must be included with the Change Proposal.

    • Category 3 BSC Configurable Item – a BSC Configurable Item that is not amended by Modifications or Change Proposals.

    • Change Submission Deadline – the date by which the Change must be submitted.

    • Change Proposal (CP) – a proposal to amend a Category 1 or 2 BSC Configurable Item(s) (not required as part of a Modification), that contains a single detailed solution and associated redline text where affecting Category 1 BSC Configurable Items. A CP can be raised by BSCCo, a BSC Agent2, a Party, Citizens Advice, Citizens Advice Scotland, the BSC Panel or one of its Committees or such other bodies representative of interested third parties as may be designated by the Authority from time to time.

    • Change Proposal Circular (CPC) – communication sent by BSCCo to the Change Distribution List when communicating BSCCo change information.

    • Change Register – a document which contains up-to-date information for each Modification Proposal, Change Proposal and Issue, including the name and organisation of the proposer, the date the Modification Proposal, Change Proposal or Issue was raised, the title and brief description of the CP, and the current status of the CP.

    • Core Industry Documents – a suite of documents set out in the Transmission Licence.

    • CP Impact Assessment – An assessment of the impacts of a CP. This involves assessing the suitability of the solution, the lead time required for implementation and commenting on whether or not the change should be made.

    • De Minimis BMRS CP – a Change Proposal which, if approved, would result in a De Minimis BMRS Change3. De Minimis BMRS CPs will be published on the BSC Website and require Committee approval.

    • De Minimis BMRS Change – a change to the data reported on the BMRS where the following conditions are satisfied:

(a) the expected cost to Elexon of implementing such change is no greater than the financial threshold set by the Panel from time to time and published on the BSC Website;

(b) the expected cost of implementing such change does not result in the aggregate cost of all De Minimis BMRS Changes implemented (or to be implemented) during that BSC Year to exceed the aggregate financial threshold set by the Panel from time to time and published on the BSC Website;

(c) it is not anticipated by the relevant Committee that such change would require BMRS users and participants to amend their systems and processes; and

(d) the relevant Committee is satisfied that the change is independent and exclusive from other changes such that there are no other related changes with which such change could reasonably be amalgamated.

    • Draft Change Proposal (DCP) – a proposal to amend a Category 1 or 2 BSC Configurable Item or an associated product that contains one or more proposed solution(s). DCPs can be issued to participants for consultation to obtain views, comments and narrow down solutions before a CP is raised. A DCP can be raised by BSCCo, a BSC Agent4, a BSC Party, Citizens Advice, Citizens Advice Scotland, the BSC Panel, or one of its Committees.

    • DCP Consultation – An assessment of a DCP. This involves providing comments and views on the DCP.

    • Effective Date – the Calendar Day on which revised BSC Section(s) and/or BSC Configurable Item(s) becomes effective.

    • Emergency Fix – an urgent correction to one or more BSC Configurable Items to correct an existing serious operational problem with the Balancing and Settlement Arrangements, for which there is no known workaround, that is causing loss of availability, loss of data integrity, an irretrievable data quality issue or significant degradation of performance. It can only be performed with the authorisation of the Chief Executive, or other persons to whom the Chief Executive has given express delegated authority (i.e. an ‘authorised person’), and is carried out in accordance with section 3.7.

    • Housekeeping Change – involves the correction of manifest errors, minor errors and inconsistencies, including typographical errors (e.g. punctuation errors, spelling mistakes, incorrect font, incorrect capitalisation) incorrect cross-referencing, and the removal of redundant text.

    • Housekeeping CP – a CP which, if approved, would result in a Housekeeping Change to one or more BSC Configurable Items on the BSC Baseline Statement5. Housekeeping CPs will be published on the BSC Website and require Committee approval.

    • Implementation Date – the calendar date on which a new release of a BSC Configurable Item is used for the purposes of implementation of the Code.

    • Issue – a pre-change process used to define and assess an issue(s) and/or solution(s).

    • Issue Group – a group established from the Standing List of Experts to consider an Issue.

    • Issue Report – a report summarising one or more Issues, any Issue Group conclusions and recommendations.

    • Market Index Data Provider (MIDP) – particular entity which is responsible for making available Market Index Data in respect of each Settlement Period as defined in the BSC.

    • Market Index Definition Statement (MIDS) – a statement which is approved by the Authority detailing each MIDP's methodology statement and Individual Liquidity Threshold, as defined in the BSC.

    • Modification Proposal – proposal of a Modification to the BSC.

    • Panel Committee – a committee established by the BSC Panel with delegated authority for changes to BSC Configurable Items, as specified on the BSC Baseline Statement.

    • Proposer – A person who raises a DCP, CP, Modification or Issue.

    • Respondent – any interested person who returns comments on an item published for feedback via the BSC Change Distribution List, BSC Change Release Distribution List or on the BSC Website.

    • Retail Energy Code - has the meaning given to the term “Retail Energy Code” in each Supply Licence.

    • Standing List of Experts – a list of persons with relevant experience and/or expertise who may be willing to be members of a Workgroup or Issue Group, established and maintained by the Panel in accordance with Section F1.5 of the BSC.

    • Third Party Applicant – an interested third party or any body representative of interested third parties that has applied to be designated as a Third Party Proposer.

    • Third Party Proposer - means any interested third party or any body representative of interested third parties in each case designated by the Panel as being permitted to make a proposal to modify the Code pursuant to Section F2.1.1(c) and in accordance with this BSCP40.

All other terms are as defined in the Balancing and Settlement Code.

3. Interface and Timetable Information

3.1 Agreement of CP Impact Assessment Timetable

CPs will be issued to the BSC Change Distribution List for Impact Assessment in an agreed timetabled Change Proposal Circular (CPC). The CP Impact Assessment timetable can be found in the Change Register on the BSC Website. The timetable will be published in line with the Panel timetable and will specify Change Submission Deadlines6, issue dates, response dates, collated response publication dates as well as target dates for Panel Committee decisions for CPs issued in a particular batch.

This section outlines the process for agreeing the timetable.

REF

WHEN

ACTION

FROM

TO

INFORMATION REQUIRED

METHOD

3.1.1

To meet publication timescales

Produce a timetable for CP Impact Assessment for the forthcoming year.

BSCCo

Timetable for issuing CPCs and response dates.

Panel Committee Meeting dates.

Internal process

3.1.2

To meet publication timescales

Issue draft CP Impact Assessment timetable for consultation.

BSCCo

BSC Change Distribution List

Draft CP Impact Assessment timetable.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.1.3

Within agreed response time (a minimum of 10 WD after 3.1.2)

Review draft timetable and submit comments.

Respondent(s)

BSCCo

Comments on draft timetable.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.1.4

To meet Panel Committee timetable dates

Finalise changes to timetable and publish on the BSC Website and notify of the publication.

BSCCo

BSC Change Distribution List

Comments from 3.1.3.

Internal Process / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.1.5

Any time during the year

Amendments to the Impact Assessment timetable can be proposed by consulting, subject to Panel Committee Approval.

BSCCo

BSC Change Distribution List

Changes to the timetable are proposed and agreed as part of a consultation.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.2 Raising a Draft Change Proposal for Impact Assessment

REF

WHEN

ACTION

FROM

TO

INFORMATION REQUIRED

METHOD

3.2.1

Any time before the Change Submission Deadline7

Draft Change Proposal (DCP) is submitted to BSCCo.

Proposer

BSCCo

DCP Guidelines in Appendix 4.2.

BSCP40/01 form (Appendix 4.1).

Any supporting documentation.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.2.2

Before CPC circulation date

BSCCo validates the form ensuring all mandatory fields are completed.

If valid, go to 3.2.5.

BSCCo

Check the form against the criteria as described in the Guidelines in Appendix 4.2.

Internal Process

3.2.3

As necessary

BSCCo returns the change to the Proposer to amend the DCP.

BSCCo

Proposer

Original BSCP40/01 form with accompanying information as to the areas to be amended.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.2.4

As appropriate

Proposer sends the amended DCP back to BSCCo.

(Go to 3.2.2.)

Proposer

BSCCo

DCP Guidelines in Appendix 4.2.

Amended BSCP40/01 form (Appendix 4.1).

Any supporting documentation.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.2.5

Within 2 WD of 3.2.2

BSCCo logs and confirms DCP number to the Proposer, carries out initial assessment and determines potentially impacted market areas and agrees in which CPC the DCP will be included.

BSCCo

Proposer

DCP Guidelines in Appendix 4.2.

Completed BSCP40/01 form (Appendix 4.1) and any supporting documentation.

Internal Process / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.2.6

On CPC circulation date

DCP circulated as part of the timetabled CPC for consultation.

BSCCo

BSC Change Distribution List

BSCP40/01 forms and any associated documentation.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.2.7

By agreed response date for that CPC

Responses are returned to BSCCo.

Respondent(s)8

BSCCo

Responses are sent to BSCCo.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.2.8

By agreed publication date9

BSCCo collates responses, issues to the Proposer and publishes on the BSC Website.

BSCCo

Proposer

Collated responses.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.2.9

As appropriate

Proposer decides on the route forward. The Proposer could:

  1. Raise a CP with a clearly Defined Solution (see section 3.4);

  2. Send the DCP to a Working Group (see section 3.3);

  3. Send an updated DCP for consultation;

  4. Withdraw DCP and notify BSCCo.

Proposer

BSCCo

If a CP is raised then use BSCP40/02 form with supporting documentation in time for the appropriate CPC Deadline, in accordance with the guidelines contained in Appendix 4.4

If an updated DCP is raised then complete BSCP40/01 form in time for the CPC Deadline, in accordance with the Guidelines contained in Appendix 4.2.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.3 Raising a Draft Change Proposal for Discussion at a Working Group

REF

WHEN

ACTION

FROM

TO

INFORMATION REQUIRED

METHOD

3.3.1

At least 4 WD before the paper day for the appropriate meeting

DCP is submitted to BSCCo for discussion at a Working Group in accordance with Section 3.2.1 – 3.2.5.

Proposer

BSCCo

Completed DCP (BSCP40/01 form) Guidelines for completing this form are contained in Appendix 4.2.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.3.2

Within 1 WD of 3.3.1

BSCCo adds the DCP onto the Agenda for the relevant Panel Committee meeting.

BSCCo

Panel Committee

Completed DCP form (BSCP40/01) outlining the issue, along with the proposed solution.

Internal Process / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.3.3

Within 1 WD of 3.3.2

BSCCo will then confirm to the Proposer which meeting it will be presented to.10

BSCCo

Proposer

Relevant Panel Committee meeting agenda.11

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.3.4

At the relevant Panel Committee meeting

The DCP is presented to the Panel Committee by the Proposer (or their nominated representative) for discussion. If the Panel Committee concludes that the subject warrants further investigation they should:

  1. Pass it to a relevant Working Group for further investigation, or if necessary form a Working Group to discuss the DCP, and

  2. Decide upon an expected date of resolution.

Panel Committee

BSCCo and Proposer

DCP is discussed and any decisions made regarding progression are minuted for clarity and circulated to all meeting attendees.

If the DCP is to be passed to a Working Group the Agenda of the next meeting of the Working Group shall be amended accordingly.

If a new Working Group is to be formed to examine the DCP the Terms of Reference should be agreed by the relevant Panel Committee and then the appropriate process should be followed.

If the DCP is passed to a Working Group the Proposer or a representative should be invited to the Working Group.

Internal Process / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.3.5

At the relevant Panel Committee meeting

If the Panel Committee conclude no further investigation is warranted then BSCCo and Proposer are notified of Panel Committee decision

Panel Committee

BSCCo and Proposer

DCP is discussed and any decisions made regarding progression are minuted for clarity and circulated.

Internal Process / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.3.6

As necessary

The Working Group will meet and discuss the DCP and develop a solution.

Working Group

DCP form (BSCP40/01) updated to outline the problem requiring further investigation, along with the minutes of the pertinent Panel Committee meeting and expected date of resolution, and the Working Group Terms of Reference.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.3.7

In time for the relevant Panel Committee Meeting

As directed by the Panel Committee the Working Group must report on their progress.

Working Group Chair

Panel Committee

Paper and Work Plan outlining progress made by the Working Group.

Meeting

3.3.8

Upon completion

The Working Group presents its findings to the Panel Committee which include either:

  1. An amended DCP;

  2. A CP for progression; or

  3. A recommendation that no CP is raised.

Working Group Chair

Panel Committee

DCP form (BSCP40/01) or a CP form (BSCP40/02) is submitted for inclusion into the next appropriate timetabled CPC, along with any required supporting documentation (e.g. redlined documents).

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.4 Raising a Change Proposal for Impact Assessment

Housekeeping CPs do not require Impact Assessment and once raised in accordance with the following process, will be submitted to the relevant Panel Committee(s) for decision in accordance with section 3.5 of this BSCP. De Minimis BMRS CPs do not require a consultation period and are therefore not subject to 3.4.9 through to 3.4.12. The relevant Panel Committee(s) will decide whether a CP should be progressed as a Housekeeping or De Minimis BMRS CP.

Any Party or Party Agent can object to the Panel Committee’s decision to treat a CP as Housekeeping or De Minimis BMRS, by using the objection process in section 3.5. Where an objection is received, BSCCo will progress the CP through the normal Impact Assessment and Panel Committee decision processes as a regular CP (i.e. a non-Housekeeping and a non-De Minimis BMRS CP). Because of the objection window, the Implementation Date for a Housekeeping or De Minimis BMRS CP shall not be earlier than 16 WDs after the date that BSCCo gives notification of the relevant Panel Committee’s decision under section 3.5.

Under certain circumstances, and with the approval of the appropriate Panel Committee(s), a regular CP can be progressed through the Impact Assessment process with a reduced timescale.

A Proposer of a CP may withdraw their CP at any time prior to the Panel Committee decision of that CP, by notifying BSCCo in writing. The withdrawn CP will remain open for a 5 WD window for adoption. During which, any interested person (including Parties and Party Agents) may adopt the CP by notifying BSCCo in writing. The adopted CP shall continue from the point at which it was withdrawn. If the CP is not adopted it shall close. BSCCo shall keep interested persons updated about withdrawn CPs via the BSC Change Distribution List.

REF

WHEN

ACTION

FROM

TO

INFORMATION REQUIRED

METHOD

3.4.1

Any time before the published Change Submission Deadline7

Completed Change Proposal form is submitted to BSCCo.

Proposer

BSCCo

CP Guidelines in Appendix 4.4.

BSCP40/02 (Appendix 4.3).

Redlined Category 1 BSC Configurable Items.

Email / or as agreed by BSCCo

3.4.2

Before the timetabled CPC circulation date

BSCCo validates the CP form, ensures all supporting information is provided including redlined versions of all Category 1 BSC Configurable Items (see Appendix 4.4 for details of Category 1 BSC Configurable Items) and CP is not vexatious or frivolous.

If valid go to 3.4.5.

BSCCo

CP Guidelines in Appendix 4.4.

Completed BSCP40/02 form (Appendix 4.3) and supporting documentation (i.e. Redlined Category 1 BSC Configurable Items).

Internal process

3.4.3

As Required

If needed BSCCo sends the CP back to the Proposer to amend.

If Proposer disagrees with BSCCo that CP is invalid then they may raise an appeal in writing, including rationale for the appeal, with the relevant Panel Committee, who will consider the appeal at their next meeting.

The decision of the relevant Committee shall be final and binding.

If the relevant Committee upholds the appeal, then proceed from 3.4.5.

If appeal is rejected, then the process ends. The appeal and the outcome of the appeal should be notified.

BSCCo

Proposer

BSC Change Distribution List

Completed BSCP40/02 form with any supplementary information.

Rationale and supporting documentation as required

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.4.4

As required and in time for timetabled CPC

Proposer sends the amended CP back to BSCCo.

(Go to 3.4.2.)

Proposer

BSCCo

Amended BSCP40/02 form and supporting documentation.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.4.5

Within 5 WD of 3.4.2

BSCCo logs the CP and confirms the CP number to the Proposer.

Carry out initial assessment and identify potentially impacted market areas to assess CP and agree the date of submission to Panel Committee.

BSCCo

Proposer

Completed BSCP40/02 form and supporting documentation.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.4.6

As necessary

BSCCo submits completed CP and additional information for CP Impact Assessment by BSC Agents.

BSCCo

BSC Agents

Completed BSCP40/02 form and supporting documentation.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.4.7

Within agreed timescales

Carry out CP Impact Assessment and return response.

BSC Agent

BSCCo

Completed Impact Assessment and supporting documentation where necessary.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.4.8

Within 1 WD of 3.4.7

BSCCo adds the estimated Central Cost(s) to the CP Form.

Where a De Minimis BMRS CP proceed to 3.5.

BSCCo

Central Costs from BSC Agents and Operational costs.

Internal Process

3.4.9

On timetabled CPC circulation date

CP and documentation are circulated as part of the timetabled CPC for Impact Assessment.

Publish the CP on the Website.

BSCCo

BSC Change Distribution List

CPC completed BSCP40/02 form, supporting documentation and response form.

Change Register.

Internal Process / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.4.10

On or before agreed response date

Responses are returned to BSCCo.

Respondent(s)

BSCCo

Responses are sent to BSCCo.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.4.11

By agreed publication date

BSCCo collates responses and publishes on the BSC Website.

BSCCo

Collated responses.

Internal Process

3.4.12

Within 1 WD of 3.4.7

BSCCo notifies the Proposer that a material comment has been returned as part of the Impact Assessment.

BSCCo

Proposer

Impact Assessment response.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.5 Panel Committee12 Decision of Change Proposals

REF

WHEN

ACTION

FROM

TO

INFORMATION REQUIRED

METHOD

3.5.1

At Panel Committee13

Present CP and CP Impact Assessments to Panel Committee for decision on progression.

BSCCo

Panel Committee

Completed BSCP40/02 form and supporting documentation, CP Impact Assessments and BSCCo paper summarising the change.

Meeting

3.5.2

At Panel Committee

The Change can be amended by the Panel Committee providing that;

  1. There is a unanimous verdict to amend the CP by the Panel Committee; and

  2. That there is no material impact on the solution.

Panel Committee

BSCCo

BSCP40/02 form and the supporting documentation.

Meeting

3.5.3

At Panel Committee

If a material impact is identified during Impact Assessment the Panel Committee can recommend an amended Change to be re-circulated to the Industry for Impact Assessment if it agrees the solution would be more robust.

Panel Committee

BSCCo

BSCP40/02 form and the supporting documentation.

Meeting

3.5.4

At Panel Committee

If CP is approved, instruct BSCCo to progress in line with section 3.6 of this BSCP.

Panel Committee

BSCCo

Panel Committee paper.

Meeting

3.5.5

Within 5 WD of 3.5.3

Update Change Register and publish revised Register and Panel Committee decision on the BSC Website.

BSCCo makes any amendments to CPs as approved by the Panel Committee and publishes the final versions of all the agreed CPs onto the BSC Website.

BSCCo

Panel Committee materials.

Change Proposals and supporting documentation (including modified CPs where appropriate).

Internal Process

3.5.6

At the same time as 3.5.5

Notify BSC Change Distribution List(where applicable) of Panel Committee decisions and circulate information on amended CPs.

BSCCo

BSC Change Distribution List

Notification circular and amended CPs with supporting documentation.

Details of how participants can object to the progression of a CP as a Housekeeping or De Minimis BMRS CP (where applicable).

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.5.7

If required, to meet industry Change Processes

If the CP is approved and the approved change impacts Core Industry Documents or the STC, raise appropriate change documentation.

Where the CP is approved, the process will continue from section 3.6 except where an objection is received to a Housekeeping or De Minimis BMRS CP in accordance with the remainder of this section 3.5.

If the CP is rejected, the process ends at this point.

BSCCo

Change Administrator for the applicable Core Industry Document or STC

Completed Change Documentation as appropriate.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.5.8

Within 15 WD of 3.5.6, for Housekeeping and De Minimis BMRS CPs (where appropriate)

Submit objection to the CP being progressed as a Housekeeping or De Minimis BMRS CP.

Party or Party Agent

BSCCo

Reasons why the Party or Party Agent believes that the CP does not meet the definition of a Housekeeping or De Minimis BMRS Change.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.5.9

Within 1 WD of receiving an objection under 3.5.8

Notify BSC Change Distribution List, the affected Panel Committee(s) and BSC Agents (where applicable) of the objection.

BSCCo

BSC Change Distribution List affected Panel Committee(s) and BSC Agents (where applicable)

Details of objection received.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.5.10

As soon as possible following 3.5.9

Update Change Register, publish revised Change Register and update the CP information on the BSC Website.

BSCCo

Revised CP form and supporting documentation.

Revised proposed Implementation Date for the CP (if required).

Internal process

3.5.11

Following 3.5.10 and in time for next available CPC

Issue CP for Impact Assessment as a regular CP in accordance with section 3.4 and then repeat the Panel Committee decision process in accordance with this section 3.5.

BSCCo

Revised CP form and supporting documentation.

Revised proposed Implementation Date for the CP (if required).

Internal process

3.6 Implementation of Change Proposals

REF

WHEN

ACTION

FROM

TO

INFORMATION REQUIRED

METHOD

3.6.1

As soon as Implementation cut off date is reached14

Amend and publish the Category 1 BSC Configurable Items ensuring all changes are highlighted.

BSCCo

Changes made using the redlined text approved in the Change Proposal.

Internal Process

3.6.2

As required to meet targeted Panel Committee meeting timescales

Amend Category 2 BSC Configurable Items ensuring changes are highlighted

BSCCo

Agreed Change Proposal.

Internal Process

3.6.3

As required to meet targeted Panel Committee meeting timescales

Submit redlined changes to Category 2 BSC Configurable Items for review as appropriate.

BSCCo

BSC Release Distribution List

Redlined BSC Configurable Items.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.6.4

As required to meet targeted Panel Committee meeting timescales

Carry out review and return comments.

Respondents(s)

BSCCo

Review comments.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.6.5

To meet Paper Day of next Panel Committee Meeting

Incorporate comments as appropriate and finalise changes.

BSCCo

Review comments.

Internal Process

3.6.6

Panel Committee paper deadline

Request that the Panel Committee approve redlined changes to BSC Category 2 Items.

BSCCo

Panel Committee

Revised Category 2 BSC Configurable Items.

Panel Committee paper number.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.6.7

At Panel Committee

Panel Committee review amended Category 2 BSC Configurable Items and make decision on progression.

Panel Committee

Revised Category 2 BSC Configurable Items.

3.6.8

Following Panel Committee approval

Publish changes to Category 2 BSC Configurable Items on the BSC Website, ensuring all changes are highlighted.

BSCCo

Revised Category 2 BSC Configurable Items.

Internal Process

3.6.9

At least 2 WD before Implementation Date

Publish clean versions of all BSC Configurable Items on the BSC Website, as appropriate.

BSCCo

Amended BSC Configurable Items.

Internal Process

3.7 Correcting Identified Errors - Emergency Fixes

REF

WHEN

ACTION

FROM

TO

INFORMATION REQUIRED

METHOD

3.7.1

On identification of problem potentially requiring an Emergency Fix

Inform BSCCo.

BSC Agent

BSCCo

Details of problem identified.

Phone / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.7.2

After 3.7.1

Assess severity of problem and inform where appropriate.

BSCCo

BSC Change Distribution List

Relevant details of problem identified.

Internal Process / Email

3.7.3

As soon as possible after 3.7.1

Analyse problem, identify possible solution(s) and inform BSCCo.

BSC Agent

BSCCo

Analysis, possible solutions and associated timescales.

3.7.4

Immediately on notification of problem

Liaise with BSC Agent to agree approach, solution and resolution timescale (or in accordance with contract where appropriate).

BSCCo

BSC Agent

Details of problem, analysis, possible solutions and associated timescales.

Phone / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.7.5

To meet agreed timescales

Resolve problem in the manner agreed above. Notify all parties as appropriate.

BSC Agent

BSCCo/All parties

Approval from the Chief Executive or authorised person.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.7.6

Within 5 WD of Implementation Date

Raise corresponding CP as necessary, to be incorporated into next appropriate BSC Release.

BSCCo

Emergency Fix Report.

Internal Process

3.7.7

Within 3 WD of 3.7.6

Publish updated Change Register on the BSC Website where appropriate.

BSCCo

Change Register.

Internal Process

3.8 Submitting a Modification Proposal

REF

WHEN

ACTION

FROM

TO

INFORMATION REQUIRED

METHOD

3.8.1

Any time

Complete Modification Proposal form and submit to BSCCo.

Proposer

BSCCo

Modification Proposal form (available from the BSC Website)

Post / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.8.2

As soon as possible after 3.8.1

Log and validate Modification Proposal and confirm receipt of Form.

BSCCo

Proposer

Completed Modification Proposal form.

Post / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.8.3

As soon as possible after decision that Modification Proposal fails to comply with requirements (see BSC Section F, 2.1.2)

Refuse to accept Modification Proposal and notify proposer, with reasons for refusal.

BSCCo

Proposer

Reasons for refusal.

Post / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.9 Development of amendments to BSC Configurable Items arising from a Modification Proposal

REF

WHEN

ACTION

FROM

TO

INFORMATION REQUIRED

METHOD

3.9.1

Where necessary

Request a decision on whether the redlined changes to the Category 1 BSC Configurable Items to support a Proposed or Alternative Modification should be developed and circulated to the industry prior to a decision on the Modification being received.15

BSCCo

BSC Panel

Relevant Modification documents.

Panel Paper

3.9.2

After 3.9.1

BSC Panel approves the request, subject to the Authority decision16 being to Approve the Proposed or Alternative Modification, or rejects the request.

BSC Panel

BSCCo

Panel Paper

3.9.3

As determined by the Panel

Develop the redlined changes to the Category 1 BSC Configurable Items.

BSCCo

Details of the changes to be made as part of the Proposed or Alternative Modification.

Internal Process

3.9.4

As appropriate

Submit redlined changes to the Category 1 BSC Configurable Items for review.

BSCCo

BSC Release Distribution List

Redlined BSC Category 1 Configurable Items.

Post / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.9.5

As required to meet targeted Panel Committee meeting timescales

Carry out review and return comments.

Respondent(s)

BSCCo

Review comments.

Post / Email / or as agreed by BSCCo

3.9.6

As appropriate

Incorporate comments as appropriate and finalise changes.

BSCCo

Review comments.

Internal Process

3.9.7

Panel Committee paper deadline

Submit redlined changes to Category 1 BSC Configurable Items as appropriate for approval. At the same time confirm Implementation Date.

BSCCo

Panel Committee

Revised BSC Configurable Items as appropriate.

Panel Committee paper number.

Post / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.9.8

At the Panel Committee

Review submission and, if approved, confirm Implementation Date.

Panel Committee

BSCCo

Revised BSC Configurable Items and Implementation Date.

Meeting / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.9.9

As appropriate

Publish approved redlined changes to Category 1 BSC Configurable Item(s).

BSCCo

BSC Release Distribution List

Approved Configurable Items.

Post / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.9.10

As appropriate

Amend Category 2 BSC Configurable Items ensuring changes are Redlined.

BSCCo

Details of the changes to be made as part of the Proposed or Alternative Modification.

Internal Process

3.9.11

As appropriate

Submit redlined Changes to Category 2 BSC Configurable Items for review as appropriate.

BSCCo

BSC Release Distribution List

Redlined BSC Configurable Items.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.9.12

Within agreed timescales

Carry out review and return comments.

Respondent(s)

BSCCo

Review comments.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.9.13

To meet Paper Day of next appropriate Panel Committee Meeting

Incorporate comments as appropriate and finalise changes in Category 2 BSC Configurable Items.

BSCCo

Review comments.

Internal Process

3.9.14

Panel Committee paper deadline

Submit revised Category 2 BSC Configurable Items as appropriate for approval.

BSCCo

Panel Committee

Revised BSC Configurable Items as appropriate.

Panel Committee paper number.

Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.9.15

Panel Committee

Review submission and, if approved, confirm Implementation Date.

Panel Committee

BSCCo

Revised BSC Configurable Items and Implementation Date.

Meeting / Email or as agreed by BSCCo

3.9.16

In time for Implementation Date of the Modification

Amend the BSC Configurable Items

BSCCo

Changes made using the text approved by the Panel Committee.

Internal Process

3.9.17

Following Panel Committee Approval

Publish changes to integer versions of Category 2 BSC Configurable Items on the BSC Website, ensuring all changes are highlighted.

BSCCo

Amended Configurable Items.

Internal Process

3.9.18

At least 2 WD before Implementation Date

Publish clean versions of all Configurable Items on the BSC Website, as appropriate.

BSCCo

Amended Configurable Items.

Internal Process

3.9.19

At least 2 WD before Implementation Date

Create a new version of the BSC Baseline Statement to include new versions of amended BSC Configurable Items and publish on the BSC Website.

BSCCo

Amended BSC Baseline Statement.

Internal Process

3.10 Market Index Definition Statement Review

REF

WHEN

ACTION

FROM

TO

INFORMATION REQUIRED

METHOD

3.10.1

At least once every 12 months,

Or, if any change in circumstances which affects the provision of Market Index Data by a Market Index Data Provider;

Or, where necessary in order to give full and timely effect to any relevant Approved Modification by the Implementation Date for that Approved Modification

Panel request review of the Market Index Definition Statement.

Panel

BSCCo

Data or report to back up request to review Market Index Definition Statement (e.g. Panel minutes).

Meeting / Email

3.10.2

As soon as possible after 3.10.1

Undertake consultation with Parties and other interested parties for at least 10 WD.

BSCCo

Parties and interested parties

Scope of consultation and Consultation Document.

Email

3.10.3

At same time as 3.10.2

Publish consultation documentation on the BSC Website.

BSCCo

Consultation documentation.

Internal Process

3.10.4

As soon as possible after the end of the consultation period in 3.10.2

Collate consultation responses and, where appropriate, hold expert group meeting to determine the recommendations and Effective Date.

BSCCo

Expert group

Consultation responses and proposed changes to Market Index Definition Statement.

Meeting

3.10.5

At next convenient Panel meeting

Present consultation report (i.e. summary of consultation responses, recommendations and Effective Date).

BSCCo

Panel

Consultation report and the revised Market Index Definition Statement.

Panel Paper

3.10.6

As soon as possible after 3.10.5

(a) Provide to the Authority copies of any written representations so made and not withdrawn, and the consultation report, Effective Date and the recommendations of the Panel.

(b) Request Authority to agree recommendations of the Panel.

BSCCo

Authority

Revised Market Index Definition Statement and consultation report.

Post / email

3.10.7

At same time as 3.10.6

Publish draft Market Index Definition Statement on BSC Website.

BSCCo

BSCCo

Draft Market Index Definition Statement.

3.10.8

As soon as possible after 3.10.6

Send decision to BSCCo.

Authority

BSCCo

Decision letter stating reasons for either approving or rejecting the revised Market Index Definition Statement.

Post / email

3.10.9

Within 5 WD of 3.10.8, and in any case 5 WD before Effective Date

Give notice of Effective Date of the revised Market Index Definition Statement.

Panel Secretary

MIDP, BSC Parties, SAA, and BMRA.

Revised Market Index Definition Statement and Effective Date.

Email / CPC

3.10.10

At the same time as 3.10.9

Issue revised and final version of Market Index Definition Statement.

BSCCo

MIDP, BSC Parties, SAA, and BMRA.

Revised Market Index Definition Statement and Effective Date.

Email

3.10.11

On the Effective Date stated in 3.10.9

Publish revised Market Index Definition Statement on the BSC Website.

Any changes to the values or Effective Dates of the Individual Liquidity Thresholds or time / product weightings to be published on the System Parameters page of the BSC Website.

BSCCo

Revised Market Index Definition Statement.

Internal Process

3.10.12

At least 2 WD before Implementation Date

Create a new version of the BSC Baseline Statement to include new version of the Market Index Definition Statement and publish on the BSC Website

BSCCo

Amended BSC Baseline Statement

Internal Process

3.11 Not Used

3.12 Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement Review

REF

WHEN

ACTION

FROM

TO

INFORMATION REQUIRED

METHOD

3.12.1

From time to time, as determined by the Panel,

Or, where necessary in order to give full and timely effect to any relevant Approved Modification by the Implementation Date for that Approved Modification

Panel request review of the Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement.

Panel

BSCCo

Data or report to back up request to review Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement (e.g. Panel minutes).

Meeting / Email

3.12.2

Within 1 WD of 3.12.1

BSCCo notifies the NETSO that a review has been initiated

BSCCo

NETSO

3.12.3

Within an agreed timescale following 3.12.2

The NETSO undertakes a review of the Loss of Load Probability calculations and provides BSCCo with any necessary updates to the calculations or associated parameters.

NETSO

BSCCo

Updates to the Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement

Email

3.12.4

As soon as possible after 3.12.3

Undertake consultation with Parties and other interested parties for at least 10 WD.

BSCCo

Parties and interested parties

Scope of consultation and consultation documentation

Email

Publish consultation documentation on the BSC Website.

BSCCo

Consultation documentation

Internal process

3.12.5

As soon as possible after the end of the consultation period in 3.12.4

Collate consultation responses and, where appropriate, hold expert group meeting to determine the recommendations and Effective Date.

BSCCo

Expert group

Consultation responses and proposed changes to Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement

Meeting

3.12.6

At next convenient Panel meeting

Present consultation report (to include summary of consultation responses, recommendations and Effective Date).

BSCCo

Panel

Consultation report and the revised Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement

Panel Paper

3.12.7

As soon as possible after 3.12.6

Provide to the Authority copies of any written representations so made and not withdrawn, the consultation report, the Effective Date and the recommendations of the Panel.

Request Authority to agree recommendations of the Panel.

BSCCo

Authority

Revised Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement and consultation report

Email

Publish draft Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement on the BSC Website.

BSCCo

Draft Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement

3.12.8

As soon as possible after 3.12.7

Send decision to BSCCo.

Authority

BSCCo

Decision letter stating reasons for either approving or rejecting the revised Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement.

Email

3.12.9

Within 5 WD of 3.12.8 and in any case 5 WD before Effective Date

Issue revised and final version of Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement and give notice of the Effective Date.

BSCCo

BSC Parties, SAA and BMRA

Revised Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement and Effective Date

Email

3.12.10

On Effective Date stated in 3.12.9

Publish revised Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement on the BSC Website.

BSCCo

Revised Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement

Internal process

3.12.11

At least 2 WD before Implementation Date

Create a new version of the BSC Baseline Statement to include new version of the Loss of Load Probability Calculation Statement and publish on the BSC Website.

BSCCo

Amended BSC Baseline Statement

Internal Process

3.13 Value of Lost Load Review

REF

WHEN

ACTION

FROM

TO

INFORMATION REQUIRED

METHOD

3.13.1

From time to time, as determined by the Panel,

Or, upon the request of the Authority

Panel request review of the Value of Lost Load.

Panel

BSCCo

Data or report to back up request to review the Value of Lost Load (e.g. Panel minutes).

Meeting / Email

3.13.2

As soon as possible after 3.13.1

Undertake consultation with Parties and other interested parties for at least 10 WD.

Where provided, the views and evidence of the Authority for a change to the Value of Lost Load should be included in the consultation.

BSCCo

Parties and interested parties

Scope of consultation and consultation documentation

Email

Publish consultation documentation on the BSC Website.

BSCCo

Consultation documentation

Internal process

3.13.3

As soon as possible after the end of the consultation period in 3.13.2

Collate consultation responses and, where appropriate, hold expert group meeting to determine whether a change to the Value of Lost Load is required and if so what this should be and what Effective Date it should take effect from.

BSCCo

Expert group

Consultation responses and, where applicable, revised proposed Value of Lost Load

Meeting

3.13.4

At next convenient Panel meeting

Present consultation report (to include summary of consultation responses, recommendations and Effective Date).

BSCCo

Panel

Consultation report and, where applicable, the revised Value of Lost Load

Panel Paper

3.13.5

If Panel agrees with the revised proposed Value of Lost Load, at the same time as 3.13.4

Panel raises a Modification Proposal to put forward the revised Value of Lost Load for implementation on the agreed Effective Date.

Panel

Modification Proposal

3.13.6

If Panel disagrees with the revised proposed Value of Lost Load or if no change is recommended to the Value of Lost Load, as soon as possible after 3.13.4

Provide to the Authority copies of any written representations so made and not withdrawn and the Panel’s report to include the decision of the Panel and its rationale for its decision.

BSCCo

Authority

Panel report and consultation responses

Email

3.14 Designation Request for Raising a Modification Proposal

REF

WHEN

ACTION

FROM

TO

INFORMATION REQUIRED

METHOD

3.14.1

Any time

Submit Designation Request Form and a draft Modification Proposal Form.

Third Party Applicant

BSCCo

Completed BSCP40/07 form (Appendix 4.13 and Appendix 4.14 for guidelines)

Completed Modification Proposal Form (available from the BSC Website)

Completed Appendix 4.15 Pro Forma Letter from Third Party Applicant

Email or other agreed means

3.14.2

Within 1 WD of 3.14.1

Acknowledge receipt.

BSCCo

Third Party Applicant

As submitted in 3.14.1

Email or other agreed means

3.14.3

Within 5WDs of 3.14.1

Validate request.

Where invalid, provide reasons for refusal and report to Panel and end process.

BSCCo

Third Party Applicant

Panel

As submitted in 3.14.1

Designation Request guidelines in 4.14

Internal process

Email or other agreed means

3.14.4

Following 3.14.3 where valid submission

Notify industry and update Change Register.

BSCCo

Panel

Third Party Applicant

BSC Change Distribution List

As submitted in 3.14.1

Email or other agreed means

3.14.5

Following 3.14.4 and at next available Panel meeting

Present Designation request and draft Modification Proposal.

Third Party Applicant

BSCCo

Panel

As submitted in 3.14.4

Electronic and verbal

3.14.6

At same time as 3.14.5

Make Designation request decision and provide reasons for decision (note the Panel may consult with Parties and interested third parties as it considers necessary before making its decision).

Panel

As submitted in 3.14.4

Electronic and verbal

3.14.7

Within 1 WD of 3.14.6

Notify designation decision, including reasons.

BSCCo

Panel

Third Party Applicant

BSC Change Distribution List

As provided from 3.14.6

Email or other agreed means

3.14.8

Within 15 WDs of 3.14.7

Where disagree with decision of Panel to designate and have valid grounds raise appeal in writing.

BSC Party17

Authority

BSCCo

As requested by the Authority

Email or other agreed means

3.14.9

Within 1 WD of 3.14.8

Acknowledge receipt of appeal and notify.

BSCCo

Panel

BSC Party

Third Party Proposer

BSC Change Distribution List

As provided from 3.14.8

Email or other agreed means

3.14.10

Following 3.14.8 and 3.14.9

Notify appeal decision.

Authority

BSCCo

As provided in 3.14.9

Email or other agreed means

3.14.11

Within 1 WD of 3.14.10

Notify appeal decision.

BSCCo

Panel

BSC Party

Third Party Proposer

BSC Change Distribution List

As submitted in 3.14.10

Email or other agreed means

3.15 Issues Process

REF

WHEN

ACTION

FROM

TO

INFORMATION REQUIRED

METHOD

3.15.1

Any time

Submit Issue Form.

Proposer of Issue

BSCCo

Completed BSCP40/04 form (Appendix 4.7)

Email or other agreed means

3.15.2

Within 1 WD of 3.15.1

Acknowledge receipt.

BSCCo

Proposer of Issue

As submitted in 3.15.1

Email or other agreed means

3.15.3

Within 5WDs of 3.15.1

Validate Issue form.

Where invalid, provide reasons for refusal and end process.

BSCCo

Proposer of Issue

As submitted in 3.15.1

Issue guidelines in 4.8

Internal process

Email or other agreed means

3.15.4

Following 3.15.3 where valid submission

Agree best route for progression

  1. Issue Group

  2. Seek advice and guidance from Panel Committee(s)

Where disagree on best route, then route 2 shall be followed.

BSCCo

Proposer of Issue

Proposer of Issue

BSCCo

As submitted in 3.15.1

Issue Group Terms of Reference (available on BSC Website)

Panel Committee Terms of Reference (available on BSC Website)

Electronic and verbal

3.15.5

Following 3.15.4

Raise and Progress Issue. Update Change Register.

BSCCo

Proposer of Issue

Issue Group or Panel Committee(s)

As agreed in 3.15.4 and as submitted in 3.15.1

Electronic and verbal

3.15.6

Following 3.15.5

Submit Issue Report.

BSCCo

Panel

As provided in 3.15.5

Electronic and verbal

4. APPENDICES

4.1 Draft CP Form

Draft Change Proposal – BSCP40/01

DCP No:

Version No:

(mandatory by BSCCo)

Title (mandatory by originator)

Description of Problem/Issue (mandatory by originator)

Justification for Change (mandatory by originator)

Proposed Solution(s) (mandatory by originator)

Version History (mandatory by BSCCo)

Has this DCP been raised for discussion by a Working Group? (optional by originator):

Y/N*(delete as appropriate)

Proposer’s Details:

Name:

Organisation:

Email Address:

Telephone Number:

Date:

Attachments: Y/N* (If Yes, No. of Pages attached: ……….)

(delete as appropriate)

4.2 Draft CP Form Guidelines

These guidelines are to be used to assist in the completion of the Draft CP Form, given in Appendix 4.1. The guidelines state who should complete each item on the form and whether it is mandatory or optional. They also give a brief description of the information that should be given for each item. For further guidance please contact BSCCo.

    • Title – mandatory completion by originator – title of CP.

    • DCP No. – mandatory completion by BSCCo – unique number allocated for each individual Draft CP.

    • Version No. – mandatory completion by originator – when first submitted by the originator, the Draft CP should have a version number of v0.1. Following discussions with BSCCo, any changes required following those discussions, the Draft CP should be updated to v1.0. Should any further amendments/additions/deletions be required to the Draft CP during its lifecycle, the version number should be updated to v2.0, v3.0, etc.

    • Description of Problem/Issues - mandatory completion by originator - a statement of the issue/problem.

    • Justification for Change – mandatory completion by originator – details of the business case for implementing the proposed change. This section should also include a brief risk assessment of the problem/issue, associated with leaving it unresolved, in terms of materiality and probability of occurrence.

    • Proposed Solution(s) – mandatory completion by originator – brief description of all possible solutions to the issue/problem, indicating any preferences and the reasons for these. The originator should also highlight any potentially impacted Configurable Items where known.

    • Version History – mandatory completion by BSCCo – details of any previous Versions of the Draft CP. Details of what has changed between versions. If this is the first version then this will be indicated in this section.

    • Has this DCP been raised for discussion by a Working Group: if yes, indicate that the DCP has been raised for discussion by a Working Group.

    • Proposer’s Details – mandatory by originator – the name, organisation, email address and telephone number of the originator and the date on which the originator raised the CP.

4.3 CP Form

Change Proposal – BSCP40/02

CP No:

Version No:

(mandatory by BSCCo)

Title (mandatory by originator)

Description of Problem/Issue (mandatory by originator)

Proposed Solution (mandatory by originator)

Justification for Change (mandatory by originator)

To which section of the Code does the CP relate, and does the CP facilitate the current provisions of the Code? (mandatory by originator)

Estimated Implementation Costs (mandatory by BSCCo)

BSC Configurable Items Affected by Proposed Solution(s) (mandatory by originator)

Impact on Core Industry Documents or System Operator-Transmission Owner Code (mandatory by originator)

Related Changes and/or BSC Releases (mandatory by BSCCo)

Requested Implementation Date (mandatory by originator)

Reason:

Version History (mandatory by BSCCo)

Proposer Details:

Name:

Organisation:

Email Address:

Telephone Number:

Date:

Attachments: Y/N* (If Yes, No. of Pages attached: ……….)

(delete as appropriate)

4.4. CP Form Guidelines

These guidelines are to be used to assist in the completion of the CP Form, given in Appendix 4.3. The guidelines state who should complete each item on the form and whether it is mandatory or optional. They also give a brief description of the information that should be given for each item. For further guidance please contact BSCCo.

    • Title – mandatory completion by originator – title of CP.

    • CP No. – mandatory completion by BSCCo – unique number allocated for each individual CP.

    • Version No. – mandatory completion by originator – when first submitted by the originator, the CP should have a version number of v0.1. Following discussions with BSCCo, any changes required following those discussions, the CP should be updated to v1.0. Should any further amendments/additions/deletions be required to the CP during its lifecycle, the version number should be updated to v2.0, v3.0, etc.

    • Description of Problem/Issues - mandatory completion by originator - a statement of the issue/problem.

    • Proposed Solution(s) – mandatory completion by originator – this is a single fully defined description of the proposed solution. For Category 1 BSC Configurable Items redlined changes must be included.

    • Justification for Change – mandatory completion by originator – details of the business case for implementing the proposed change. This section should also include a brief assessment of the risk associated with leaving the problem/issue unresolved, in terms of materiality and probability of occurrence.

    • To which section of the Code does the CP relate, and does the CP facilitate the current provisions of the Code? – All CPs should be raised in line with BSC section F 3.1.2 ensuring that changes to BSC Configurable Items should continue to facilitate the provisions as detailed in the Code and should not impose new obligations or restrictions of a material nature on Parties and Party Agents (or classes thereof) which are not authorised or envisaged by, or subsidiary to, the rights and obligations of the Parties under the Code. As such the originator should highlight the section of the BSC that their proposed change is derived from and if the proposed CP facilitates the existing arrangements in the BSC.

    • Estimated Implementation Costs – mandatory by BSCCo – These will be broken down into Central System Costs and BSCCo Operational Costs where appropriate.

    • Impact on BSC Configurable Item(s) – mandatory completion by originator – a list of all BSC Configurable Items potentially affected by proposed solution. Details of how each BSC Configurable Item will be affected should be included, if known, and redlining of Category 1 BSC Configurable Items must be completed.

    • Impact on Core Industry Documents or System Operator – Transmission Owner Code – mandatory completion by originator, however, BSCCo can advise if originator is unsure of all the impacts on documents – list of all documents potentially affected by proposed solution. These documents include any changes that will be needed to the EMDS or REC Products. Details of how each document will be affected will also need to be included.

    • Requested Implementation Date and Associated Reasons – mandatory by originator – identification of any critical milestone date(s) which need to be considered when generating possible solutions, with reasons for these. If change can be implemented at any time i.e. with no time constraints, this should be stated. This will be updated to the agreed Implementation Date once the Panel Committee has voted.

    • Version History – mandatory completion by BSCCo – details of any previous versions of a Draft CP or details of what has changed between CP versions. If this is the first version then this will be indicated in this section.

    • Proposer’s Details – mandatory by originator – the name, organisation, email address and telephone number of the originator and the date on which the Proposer raised the CP.

4.5. Section not used.

4.6. Section Not used

4.7 Issue Form

Issue Form - BSCP40/04

Issue Number

(mandatory by BSCCo)

Issue Title (Mandatory by originator)

Issue Description (Mandatory by originator)

Justification for Examining Issue (Mandatory by originator)

Potential Solution(s) (Optional by originator)

Proposer’s Details

Name

Organisation

Email Address

Telephone Number

Date

4.8. Issue Form Guidelines

These guidelines are to be used to assist in the completion of the Issue Form, contained in Appendix 4.7. The guidelines state who should complete each item on the form and whether it is mandatory or optional. They also give a brief description of the information that should be given for each item. For further support on completing this Issue Form, please contact BSCCo. Once completed this form should be submitted to BSCCo.

    • Issue Number –mandatory to be completed by BSCCo once the proposed issue has been received. This is a unique number.

    • Issue Title – mandatory and is completed by the proposer of the Issue at the time the issue is raised. This should be unique where possible.

    • Issue Description – mandatory and is completed by the proposer of the Issue. The description should include as much detail as possible of the issue being encountered.

    • Potential Solution(s) - optional by originator – This is to be completed where the proposer of the Issue has potential solutions that they want to be discussed as part of a potential solution to the issue.

    • Justification for Examining Issue – mandatory by proposer of the Issue – details of the business case for examining the issue. This section should also include a brief assessment of the risk associated with leaving the problem/issue unresolved, in terms of materiality and probability of occurrence.

    • Proposer’s Details – mandatory completion by proposer of the Issue – the name, organisation, email address and telephone number of the proposer. This should include details of any originators of the Issue, for example if BSCCo is raising an Issue on behalf of another participant.

4.9. Not Used

4.10 Not Used

4.11 Not Used

4.12. Not Used

4.13 Designation Request Form

Designation Request Form - BSCP40/07

Request Number

(mandatory by BSCCo)

Title of proposed Modification (Mandatory by originator – please also attach draft Modification Proposal Form, which can be found on the BSC Website and must meet the requirement in Section F2.1.2 of the BSC, and the signed letter from section 4.15)

Rationale for Requesting Designation (Mandatory by originator – this must include any information on what other steps, if any, have been taken to have the Code issue or defect addressed)

Reasons why Applicant has an interest in the Code/issue (Mandatory by originator – this may include evidence of being materially affected by the issue)

Additional Details which may support the application (Optional by originator)

Proposer Name

Organisation

Email Address

Telephone Number

Date

4.14. Designation Request Form Guidelines

These guidelines are to be used to assist in the completion of the Designation Request Form, given in Appendix 4.13. The guidelines state who should complete each item on the form and whether it is mandatory or optional. They also give a brief description of the information that should be given for each item. For further guidance please contact BSCCo.

    • Request Number –mandatory to be completed by BSCCo once the request has been received. This is a unique number.

    • Title of Proposed Modification – mandatory and is completed by the originator at the time the request is raised. This must match the title on the draft Modification Proposal Form that accompanies your Designation Request.

    • Rationale for Requesting Designation – mandatory and is completed by the originator. You should include as much detail as possible on your reasons for requesting Designation. This should include any information on your attempts to find a Party to raise the Modification, the reason they will not raise or ‘sponsor’ this Modification and any information on other industry discussions or forum discussion you have had on the Modification.

    • Reasons why Applicant has an interest in the Code/issue – mandatory by originator. You need to explain how the issue impacts you and what it is about the proposed Modification that makes you an interested party in it. If you are acting for another party/parties (for example, a trade association acting for its members) this should be explained.

    • Additional Details which may support the application – optional by originator – if there are any other details that you believe will support your request, please include them.

    • Proposer’s Details – mandatory completion by originator – the name, organisation, email address and telephone number of the applicant.

4.15 Pro Forma Letter from Third Party Proposer

To:

Elexon Limited as the Balancing and Settlement Code (the “BSC”) Company (“BSCCo”)

[insert registered office address]

[insert date]

Dear Sirs,

Application to be designated by the Panel as a Third Party Proposer pursuant to Section F2.1A.1 of the Balancing and Settlement Code

By writing this letter, and submitting a Designation Request Form and a draft Modification Proposal Form we are applying to be designated as a Third Party Proposer under the Section F (Modification Procedures) of the BSC.

Unless otherwise stated, or the context otherwise requires, any capitalised term in this letter shall have the meaning given to it in the BSC.

We acknowledge that we have obtained a copy of the latest versions of Section B (The Panel), Section C (BSCCo and its Subsidiaries), Section F and Section H (General) and Section X-1 (General Glossary) of the BSC as well as BSC Procedure 40 from the BSC Website.

In consideration of BSCCo and/or the Panel considering our application to be designated as a Third Party Proposer, we hereby agree with each of you that we shall be bound by:

a) the terms of Section B1, B3 and B4.6 (the Panel); Section C1 and C3 (BSCCo and its Subsidiaries), Section F (Modification Procedures) and Section H7.1, H8 and H9 (General) of the BSC; and

b) the terms of BSC Procedure 40,

for the purposes of our application to be designated as a Third Party Proposer and the consideration of our modification proposal under the Modification Procedures as if we were a party to the BSC for the purposes of those Sections and BSC Procedures.

We acknowledge and agree that:

a) during our application to be appointed as a Third Party Proposer the provisions of paragraph 2.1A of Section F (Modification Procedures) of the BSC provide a right of appeal to the Authority should the Panel reject our application and that should our application be rejected our sole and exclusive remedy will be to refer the matter for determination to the Authority in accordance with that paragraph and we accept that its determination will be final, conclusive and binding; and

b) we will not make any claim in damages or any other claim of a financial nature against Elexon Limited or any Panel Member and we hereby waive (to the fullest extent permitted by law) any such claim against Elexon Limited or any Panel Member and release each from any such liability in respect of any breach by Elexon Limited or the Panel of any provision of the Code or in tort (including negligence) or otherwise.

Nothing in this letter shall exclude or limit liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence by Elexon Limited or any Panel Member or resulting from fraudulent misrepresentation.

This letter shall expire following the later of:

a) the final determination (whether by the Panel or the Authority) that we have not been designated as a Third Party Proposer;

b) the withdrawal of the Modification Proposal proposed by us; or

c) the final determination (whether by the Panel or the Authority) as to whether the Modification Proposal proposed by us should be approved or rejected.

This letter shall be governed by, and construed in all respects in accordance with, the laws of England and Wales.

Yours faithfully,

……………………………………………………………..

signed by [insert name] being a Director and signing this letter for and on behalf of [insert full name of company]

1 The BSC Baseline Statement specifies which Panel Committee(s) are responsible for the approval of each BSC Configurable Item.

2 Proposals raised by BSC Agents will only be validated and logged as a CP with BSCCo’s consent.

3 The relevant Committee will determine whether a CP should be progressed as a De Minimis BMRS CP

4 Proposals raised by BSC Agents will only be validated and logged as a DCP with BSCCo’s consent.

5 The relevant Panel Committee will decide whether a CP should be progressed as a Housekeeping CP.

6 Originators should be aware that if Central Costs are needed this can take between 5 and 15 Working Days.

7 The Change Submission Deadline is produced as part of the CPC batching timetable in Section 3.1.

8 Please note lack of any response to a CPC does not indicate a negative response.

9 Timescales for publication are determined in Section 3.1.

10 Where the Working Group consists of only BSCCo and the originator, with the aim of producing redline text in a CP, no approval will be sought from the Panel Committees.

11 Only one of the Panel Committees need agree that a Working Group is required in order for a Working Group to be established.

12 Some BSC Configurable Items are jointly owned by more than one Panel Committee, as specified in the BSC Baseline Statement, and so will require approval by each relevant Panel Committee

13 The Proposer may attend the Panel Committee meeting.

14 Implementation cut off is 6 months for system changes and 4 months for document only changes or as agreed by the Panel Committee.

15 This request should only be made where Elexon has identified that there would be insufficient time to develop the necessary changes to Configurable Items with the appropriate amount of notice to participants following notification of the Authority’s decision. The development of such changes would not commence until after submission of the relevant Final Modification Report to the Authority. If the Modification were subsequently rejected by the Authority, such changes would not be implemented.

16 Except where a Modification Proposal is considered to be a Self-Governance Modification Proposal

17 Please note that Third Party Applicants can also appeal to the Authority where they disagree with the Panel’s decision not to designate them as a Third Party Proposer.