P416 Introducing a route of appeal for the Annual Budget in line with the proposals for the Retail Energy Code

P416 seeks to amend the BSC to include an appeals mechanism that BSC Parties could use to challenge items in the Annual Budget.

If Parties’ concerns over the Balancing and Settlement Code Company (BSCCo) Annual Budget are not being satisfactorily addressed by the BSCCo Board, the mechanism for further contesting them would be by raising a Resolution to the BSCCo Board. If that Resolution does not reach a satisfactory conclusion, the Party could raise further Resolutions to remove Board members.

The Proposer contends that these are inefficient and disproportionate processes for Parties to address their concerns with the BSCCo budget.

This Modification seeks to amend the BSC to include an appeals mechanism that could be used to challenge items in the Annual Budget in line with the appeals mechanism detailed in proposals for the Retail Energy Code.

Podcast

Listen to a podcast from lead analyst Chris Arnold which explains the proposal.

Elexon Communications · P416 Podcast ‘Route of appeal for the Annual Budget’

Current Status

Submission

Initial Written Assessment

Assessment Procedure

Report Phase

With Authority

Awaiting Implementation

Implemented

With Authority

Report Phase

The Panel agreed to send P416 out for a 10 Working Day consultation at its meeting on 13 May 2021 with an initial recommendation to reject the proposed solution. The Report Phase Consultation closed on 3 June 2021. The Panel considered the Draft Modification Report for P416 at its meeting on 10 June 2021 and made its final recommendations. The BSC Panel recommended:

That P416 DOES NOT better facilitate any of the Applicable BSC Objectives; and
That P416 should be rejected.

Assessment Procedure

P413 was approved to progress to the Assessment Procedure phase by the BSC Panel on 10th September 2020.

Workgroup 1

The first Workgroup meeting was held on 14 December 2020. You can find all materials related to the Workgroup here.

Workgroup 2

The second Workgroup meeting was held on 22 January 2021. You can find all materials related to the Workgroup here.

Workgroup 3

The third Workgroup meeting was held on 15 March 2021. You can find all materials related to the Workgroup here.

The Assessment Procedure Consultation was issued on 7 April 2021 with responses invited until 22 April 2021.

Workgroup 4

The fourth Workgroup meeting was held on 27 April 2021. You can find all materials related to the Workgroup here.

The P416 Assessment Report was presented to the Panel at its meeting on Thursday 13 May 2021 (Panel 314/05). The Panel made an initial recommendation that P416 should be rejected.

P416 Assessment Report

Size 1.51 MB Document Date 06/05/2021

P416 Assessment Procedure Consultation

Size 1.36 MB Document Date 07/04/2021

Submission

P416 was raised by British Gas Ltd on 5 November 2020

The BSC Panel consider the Initial Written Assessment at its meeting on 12 November 2020

Proposed Progression

The IWA proposes P416 is not a self-governance Modification and should be progressed to Assessment Procedure for an assessment by a Workgroup.

The Initial Written Assessment will be presented to the BSC Panel at its meeting on 12 November 2020.

P416 Initial Written Assessment v1

Size 664.52 KB Document Date 05/11/2020

P416 Proposal Form

Size 607.07 KB Document Date 05/11/2020

You are here:

P416 Introducing a route of appeal for the Annual Budget in line with the proposals for the Retail Energy Code

Current Status

With Authority

Report Phase

Assessment Procedure

Submission

My BSC

Cookie use