Trading Disputes and Decisions
Trading Disputes provide a mechanism for correcting identified Settlement Errors. It allows for energy that was incorrectly calculated to be re-calculated, and the corrected Trading Charges distributed accordingly. The Trading Disputes Committee (TDC) hears all Disputes that we think are valid.
Articles of Interest
How it relates to you
Trading Dispute: trading charges
A Trading Dispute can arise when errors in the data, processes and/or rules used for the purposes of Settlement affect Trading Charges paid to or from Parties.
Any BSC Party can raise a Trading Dispute.
If you have Category O authorisation (see BSCP38 ‘Authorisations’) you can raise a Trading Dispute by completing a form in BSCP11 ‘Trading Disputes’ and sending it to us with supporting information, e.g. Data Flows, Bid Offer Acceptances or consumption information.
Trading Dispute: credit default
Trading Disputes can also arise as a result of errors in the determination of whether a Party is in Credit Default.
A generator or National Grid can claim a Manifest Errors where a Bid or Offer was accepted in error.
You can claim for unavoidable and material losses incurred as a consequence of not being able to communicate Physical Notifications to National Grid during unplanned outages by National Grid.
The Q8 committee is an extension of the Trading Disputes Committee (TDC) and hears trading compensation claims. The same members who sit on the TDC also form the Q8 Committee.
Elexon manage the process and investigate the Trading Dispute in consultation with any relevant Parties, Agents and/or experts.
Trading Disputes is a remedial technique in Elexon’s Performance Assurance Framework.
We assess all Trading Disputes against the three criteria that must be met. The results of our assessment are sent to you (the ‘Raising Party’) and any other affected Party.
When a Trading Dispute is raised, it is subject to the following three criteria:
- Timeliness (was the Dispute raised within the timescales set out in BSCP11?)
- Settlement Error (was there an error in the data and/or processes used for Settlement arising from a failure to follow the provisions of the BSC such that the error affected Trading Charges?)
- Materiality (was the effect on Trading Charges greater than £3000?)
When raising a Trading Dispute, the Raising Party may request that the TDC considers whether to grant exceptional circumstances. Exceptional circumstances, if granted by the TDC, waive the requirement for the Trading Dispute to be raised in accordance with the applicable Dispute Deadline and allow corrections to be made up to 20 months from the date the Trading Dispute is raised.
Please refer to the Guidance Note for further information on raising a claim for exceptional circumstances.
Please refer to our training video below for an overview of the Trading Disputes process and for further explanation of the Trading Disputes criteria and exceptional circumstances.
If we believe the Trading Dispute is invalid and you as Raising Party are happy with the findings then we will close the Trading Dispute.
If you disagree with us finding the Trading Dispute invalid we are able to refer the case to the Trading Disputes Committee (TDC) for consideration.
If the Trading Dispute is valid, we will take it to the Trading Disputes Committee (TDC) who will assess the dispute.
We notify the Raising Party and affected Parties of the TDC’s decisions after the meeting. The Raising Party or any affected Party has the option to attend the Trading Disputes Committee meeting where the Trading Dispute will be heard.
If the TDC doesn’t reach a majority decision or a Party disagrees with the TDC decision, the TDC or the Party can refer the matter to the BSC Panel
Elexon Trading Dispute Decisions
Disputes that we think are invalid can be closed without being heard by the TDC. However, this is only if, within 14 days of our decision:
- The Raising Party doesn’t object to the findings
- No affected Parties object to our findings
- No other Parties have contacted us to state that they believe they are an affected Party but weren’t informed of our findings
If you don’t notify me, how can I know whether I’m affected?
The spreadsheet below lists our findings for recent Disputes.
If a Dispute is invalid and you haven’t been contacted as an affected Party but believe you should have been, please contact us and we will take the Dispute to the TDC.
Elexon disputes decisions
Register of TDC Determinations
The Register of Determinations is a document which contains non-confidential details of all Trading Disputes which were determined by the Trading Disputes Committee (TDC) at its meetings.
It is used to track decisions made and agreed by the TDC for each Trading Dispute which has been presented at a TDC meeting.
This document is updated and published on the Elexon website every 5 working days after a TDC meeting.
Elexon has archived the records of all Trading Disputes which were determined before 7 February 2019. These records are available on request.
TDC Register of Determinations
EAC/AA Finding Forms
Every month, the TDC authorises the correction of data in the Non Half Hourly market to resolve errors associated with erroneous large Estimated Annual Consumptions (EACs) and Annualised Advances (AAs) in the Post-Final Settlement Run. A Finding Form is issued each month setting out the TDC’s decision.